The All Tournament Teams for 2016 were announced at each final. MVPs for A, B and C were Ryan Maloney (Victor), Nick Mabe (Thomas) and Ben Emerson (Penn Yan). Players were selected on the basis of their performances in the Section Five Tournaments.

The Players of the Year were announced at the conclusion of the Class A game. The award for Offensive Player of the Year was awarded to Ryan Maloneyof Victor. The award for Defensive Player of the Year was awarded to Jared Conners of Pittsford. The award for Sportsman of the Year was awarded to Gage Ponsetti of Penn Yan.

Gates Chili (Class A), Churchville-Chili (Class B) and UPrep (Class C) were awarded the Steve Morgan Sportsmanship Awards by the Genesee Valley Lacrosse Officials Association.

2016 All Tournament Team Class A
Player	Team	Position	Grade
T.D. Ierlan	Victor	Midfield F/O	12
Max Lambert	Victor	Attack	12
Jack Callahan	Victor	LSM	12
Chayse Ierlan	Victor	Goalie	10
Jon Perotto	Pittsford	Attack	12
Colby Barker	Pittsford	Midfield	11
Michael Gigantelli	Pittsford	Defense	12
Jared Conners	Pittsford	Defense	12
Peter Schwab	Penfield	Midfield	11
Conor Bollin	Schroeder	A/M	10
Ryan Maloney	Victor	MVP Attack	12
2016 All Tournament Team Class B
Trevor Ford	Thomas	Midfield	12
Travis Ford	Thomas	Attack	10
CJ Battiaglia	Thomas	Defense	10
Matt Yonko	Thomas	Goalie	10
Devin Andrews	Canandaigua	Attack	11
Carson Greene	Canandaigua	Atttack	11
Johnny DelForte	Canandaigua	Attack	12
David York	Canandaigua	Defense	12
Matt Cobb	Churchville	Goalie	12
Jack Brennan	Irondequoit	A/M	9
Nick Mabe	Thomas	MVP (Midfield)	10
2016 All Tournament Team Class C
Player	Team	Position	Grade
Craig Gerhardt	Penn Yan	Attack	12
Austin Fingar	Penn Yan	Midfield	12
John Luppino	Penn Yan	Defense	12
Gage Ponsetti	Penn Yan	Goalie	12
Nick Tschetter	Aquinas	Midfield	12
Jamir Jones	Aquinas	Midfield	12
Tyler Olbrich	Aquinas	Defense	11
Jack Owens	Aquinas	Defense	11
Jon Ecker	Wayne	A/M	12
Dylan Joy	Gananda	Defense	12
Ben Emerson	Penn Yan	MVP (A/M)	10
2016 Special Awards
Gage Ponsetti	Penn Yan	Section Five Sportsman of the Year
Ryan Maloney	Victor	Section Five Offensive Player of the Year
Jared Conners	Pittsford	Section Five Defensive Player of the Year
Genesee Valley Lacrosse Officials Association Steven R. Morgan Sportsmanship Award Gates Chili High School (Class A) Churchville-Chili High School (Class B) University Prep (Class C)